This is the second of a two-part series on knowing the difference between negative results and negative evidence. Part one of the series can be read here.
Definitions
Negative results occur when you come up empty-handed in your search, while negative evidence is the absence of expected information that might lead you to a different conclusion. Negative evidence will tell you something. Negative results will not.
Last week I wrote about how I still have not found Edith McKamey in any record after April 1910. Many times we search for our ancestors, but they’re just not there. You think you know where they should be at a particular time, but they’re not. Those are negative results and don’t necessarily tell you anything about your ancestor’s life.1 As a reminder in your genealogy research, keep track of those searches so you don’t do them again.
Negative Evidence
Negative evidence is completely different. It’s when you don’t find your ancestor in a particular situation or record set and it does tell you something.2 Let me give you an example…
If you tracked an ancestor in the tax rolls and suddenly he no longer appears. Several scenarios must be considered as to what happened to him:
- He became too old and was exempt from paying taxes (check local laws for time and place).
- He could have moved.
- He could have died.
His absence from the list says something about his life. You’d think he’d be there, but his name not showing up speaks volumes. That’s negative evidence. And yes, you need to cite that as well. From there, you make a plan to look for him in another census, a death record, etc.
Elizabeth Shown Mills has a wonderful article entitled “Negative Evidence vs. Negative Findings”. You can read it here. She gives a wonderful explanation to further explain this concept.
Finally
Negative evidence can be very powerful to your research. It’s up to you to determine what it means and how you can use it to move forward.
Genealogy tip: The more you work with records, the more you will find negative searches and negative evidence. Get comfortable with both and it will improve your research skills.
Do you have ancestors who are tough to find? I can help. Begin by clicking below to start uncovering your elusive ancestors.
1“Appendix D – Glossary,” Genealogy Standards, Second Edition (Nashville, Tennessee: Turner Publishing Company, 2019), p. 82.
2Ibid. p. 81.
One thought on “Negative Results vs. Negative Evidence: How To Tell The Difference”